Arcana vs Venly : Choosing the Better Auth Service for Your Project‍

by

Product at Arcana

|

Jun 2, 2023

Introduction

Improving the user experience during the authorization process is crucial for the success of any online platform. A simplified and secure login experience is necessary for today's digital age. This is where authentication services like Arcana and Venly come in. Both of the mentioned ideas aim to provide a seamless authentication experience for users. However, they differ in their approach and technology.

Are you looking for the right authentication service for your online platform? With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to make the right choice. That's where we come in - we've done the research and comparison for you!

Already Sure about choosing Arcana as your Authentication Solution?
Book a Demo Now!!

Let's look at two popular authentication services - Arcana and Venly. By examining their unique features and benefits, we can help you determine which service is best suited for your needs.

What is Arcana Network?

Arcana Network is an authentication idea that forms its roots in advocating Web3 Onboarding in a Secure and User-Friendly Way. 

Designed for developers and users, Arcana Auth is easy to integrate and offers a simple yet secure, customizable user experience powered by cutting-edge cryptographic algorithms and distributed key generation system that ensures no single entity owns the user's keys.

What is Venly?

Venly on the other hand, is a comprehensive toolkit to scale your project in niches like wallet services, marketplace solutions, NFT tools, and more.

Venly in this particular retrospect has its Wallet solution to Onboard your users with our easy-to-implement wallet solution. Powered with the SSS algorithm, the key management is mostly done on the client side.

Decoding: "Competitive Advantages of Arcana over Venly”

  1. Security and Key Management

Arcana Authentication smartly addresses and deals with the complexities involved in key generation and management for onboarding blockchain applications by implementing a state-of-the-art distributed key generation protocol combined with the cutting-edge non-custodial, embedded Arcana wallet. 

This combination of technologies simplifies generating and managing of private keys for users, making it more accessible and secure for them to engage with decentralized applications. In simpler terms, The private key is a secret associated with a user's Arcana wallet and is generated using a distributed key generator (DKG) component of the Arcana Auth product. It cannot be accessed by anyone other than the user. The Arcana wallet allows users to export their private key if they want to access their data or assets using a different wallet. However, the private key is not removed from the Arcana Network after it is exported.

On the other hand, Venly has another way of addressing the key and security management, the project binds its roots to give the client full responsibility for the key access and uses SSS Algorithm to ensure the safety of the data. This particular approach is in some criteria said to be less secure when compared to a hybrid approach to securing the credentials.

  1. Integration and Infrastructural Edge

Arcana Auth offers an easy-to-implement SDK that usually outperforms ecosystem standards regarding integration. With comprehensive documentation and support available for developers who need assistance, the integration time for Arcana Auth is typically just 10 minutes, while ensuring the fastest login time and compatibility with different tech stacks. 

The SDK also supports various authentication methods, including social media logins, email/password combinations, and integration with various blockchain wallets, making it easy for developers to offer their users a range of signing-in options. This seamless integration process can save developers significant time and resources, allowing them to focus on building and scaling their applications.

Also, when the infrastructure is compared to Venly, Arcana has the edge not only with the login time but also with higher scalability, as Arcana covers most of the relevant blockchains with smooth interoperability throughout different dApps in the ecosystem. 

Also in the case of Social Login implementations, Arcana Supports more social platforms when compared to Venly, for example, GitHub and Discord. Should also mention about “Support”

  1. Pricing Analysis

Arcana always stands out from the competition when it comes to pricing, though in this specific case of comparison, the pricing structures of both services are a bit different. Venly offers fixed tiers of monthly plans that start from around $49 and goes up to more depending on the enterprise plan.

Whereas when it comes to Arcana, the pricing is based on Monthly Active users which offers a free plan that supports up to 2000 Monthly Active Users and includes features such as customizable UI and wallet integration. Furthermore, even when it comes to paid plans, Arcana Auth is the lowest charged service in the ecosystem at just $0.025 per Monthly Active User. Hence, Arcana Auth ensures accessibility to its platform for everyone, regardless of their budget or project size, by offering a generous free plan and affordable paid plans.

Authentication Methods: Arcana vs Venly

Authentication methods are an important consideration when choosing an authentication service like Arcana or Venly. Both services offer a range of authentication methods, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. Here's a closer look at the authentication methods offered by Arcana and Venly:

Arcana Authentication offers a two-factor authentication method that involves the use of a username and password, along with a second factor such as a token or biometric authentication. This provides an extra layer of security to help prevent unauthorized access to your application or website. Arcana also offers a range of authentication methods beyond the two-factor authentication, including SMS-based authentication, voice authentication, and biometric authentication.

Venly Authentication, on the other hand, offers a passwordless authentication method that eliminates the need for users to remember passwords. Instead, Venly uses a cryptographic authentication method that relies on public and private keys to authenticate users. This method is based on blockchain technology, which provides a high level of security and ensures that each user's identity is verified before they can access your application or website.

While both Arcana and Venly offer strong authentication methods, the choice of which one to use will depend on your specific needs and requirements. If your application or website requires a high level of security, Arcana's two-factor authentication and biometric authentication methods may be the better option. If you want to simplify the authentication process for your users and reduce the risk of password-related security issues, Venly's passwordless authentication method may be the better choice.

In summary, both Arcana and Venly offer robust authentication methods that can help to protect your application or website from unauthorized access. The choice of which one to use will depend on your specific needs and requirements, as well as your budget and other factors. By carefully evaluating the authentication methods offered by both services, you can make an informed decision and choose the right authentication service for your project.

Arcana vs Venly: Which is Better for Your Project?

When it comes to choosing between Arcana and Venly for your project, there are several factors to consider. Both services offer a range of authentication methods and security features, as well as customization options and ease of use. Here's a closer look at how Arcana and Venly compare in terms of these key factors:

Authentication Methods: Both Arcana and Venly offer strong authentication methods, but they differ in their approach. Arcana offers a two-factor authentication method that includes username and password, along with a second factor like token or biometric authentication. Venly, on the other hand, uses a passwordless authentication method based on blockchain technology that eliminates the need for passwords.

Security Features: Both Arcana and Venly offer a range of security features, including multi-factor authentication, encryption, and identity verification. However, Venly's use of blockchain technology provides an extra layer of security, making it a popular choice for high-risk applications.

Customization Options: Arcana offers a range of customization options for its security policies, including the ability to set policies based on user roles and devices. Venly, on the other hand, offers less customization but is highly flexible and can be easily integrated into existing systems.

Ease of Use: Both Arcana and Venly are user-friendly and easy to use, but Venly's passwordless authentication method may be more convenient for users who struggle with password management.

Overall, the choice between Arcana and Venly will depend on your specific needs and requirements. If you need a high level of security and want to eliminate the need for passwords, Venly may be the better choice. If you require more customization options or prefer a more traditional authentication method, Arcana may be the better option.

In addition to these factors, it's also important to consider cost, implementation process, and support options when choosing between Arcana and Venly for your project. By carefully evaluating these factors and considering your specific needs, you can make an informed decision and choose the authentication service that is best suited for your project.

How to Choose the Right Authentication Solution for Your Business

Choosing the right authentication solution for your business can be a daunting task, especially with so many options available in the market. Here are some key factors to consider when choosing an authentication solution, along with how Arcana and Venly stack up in each of these areas:

  1. Security: Security is the most important consideration when choosing an authentication solution. Make sure the solution you choose offers robust security features such as multi-factor authentication, encryption, and identity verification. Both Arcana and Venly offer strong security features, with Venly's use of blockchain technology providing an extra layer of security.

  2. Ease of Use: A good authentication solution should be easy to use and integrate into your existing systems. Both Arcana and Venly are user-friendly and easy to integrate, but Venly's passwordless authentication method may be more convenient for users.

  3. Customization: Customization options are important if you need to set specific security policies for different users or devices. Arcana offers a range of customization options, while Venly is more flexible and can be easily integrated into existing systems.

  4. Cost: Cost is an important consideration for any business. Arcana and Venly both offer competitive pricing options, but the cost will depend on your specific needs and the number of users you have.

  5. Implementation Process: The implementation process should be smooth and easy to minimize downtime for your business. Both Arcana and Venly offer easy implementation processes, but Venly's passwordless authentication method may require more setup time.

By considering these factors and evaluating your specific business needs, you can make an informed decision and choose the right authentication solution for your business. Both Arcana and Venly offer strong authentication solutions, but the choice will ultimately depend on your specific needs and preferences.

In summary, when choosing an authentication solution for your business, consider factors such as security, ease of use, customization options, cost, and implementation process. By evaluating these factors and comparing solutions such as Arcana and Venly, you can choose the right authentication solution for your business needs.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Arcana and Venly are both reputable companies in the blockchain industry that offer unique and valuable services and solutions.

In our opinion, Arcana stands out in terms of its ease of integration, interoperability, and affordability. Also, Arcana Auth has a significant advantage over them regarding core infrastructure. As a more advanced product with a stronger focus on security, non-custodial solutions, and customization options, Arcana Auth is the clear choice in almost every situation where user wallet management and recoverability are crucial factors. 

Overall, Venly is a very utility-rich product for NFT Infra Scaling, Primitive Social media-based logins, and user-friendliness. But, Arcana Auth is the superior choice for more complex and advanced Web3 projects that require a higher level of security and customization.

Book a demo and get to know more about Arcana Auth.

Schedule a Demo

The call is completely free and no commitment is required.

Copyright © Arcana Technologies Ltd. All rights reserved.

Schedule a Demo

The call is completely free and no commitment is required.

Copyright © Arcana Technologies Ltd. All rights reserved.

Schedule a Demo

The call is completely free and no commitment is required.

Schedule a Demo

The call is completely free and no commitment is required.

Schedule a Demo

The call is completely free and

no commitment is required.