Arcana vs Magic : Logging into the Better Authentication Solution‍

by

Product at Arcana

|

May 30, 2023

Introduction

Choosing the right authentication service is key to improving the user experience during the authorization process, which, in turn, can facilitate the adoption of your product by users. Authentication is a crucial component of any online platform, and the need for a secure and simplified login experience is more important than ever. Magic Link and Arcana Network are two authentication services that aim to address this need, but they differ in their approach and technology

In this article, we will compare two of the most relevant authentication services, Arcana and Magic, to help you understand which authentication service is right for your needs. By examining the features and benefits of each service, we aim to provide you with a clear understanding of their respective strengths and weaknesses, and ultimately, help you make an informed decision on which Auth Service to choose.

What is Arcana Network?

Arcana Network is an authentication idea that forms its roots in advocating Web3 Onboarding in a Secure and User-Friendly Way.

Designed for developers and Web3 users, Arcana Auth is easy to integrate and offers a simple yet secure, and customizable user experience for signing blockchain transactions. It is powered by cutting-edge cryptographic algorithms and a built-in distributed key generation subsystem that ensures no single entity owns or manages the user's keys.

What is Magic Link?

Magic Link, employs a passwordless authentication method that provides users with a one-time login link via email or SMS. This eliminates the need for users to remember passwords and enhances security, as users do not have to store passwords on their devices. 

Furthermore, Magic Link's compatibility with various programming languages and frameworks makes it a convenient option for developers. This allows them to easily integrate Magic Link into their existing systems and applications.

Arcana’s Edge over Magic: A Comprehensive Study

  1. Security & Key Management

Arcana Auth abstracts the complexities involved in key generation and management for onboarding blockchain applications by implementing a state-of-the-art distributed key generation protocol combined with the cutting-edge non-custodial, embedded Arcana wallet. This combination of technologies simplifies generating and managing of private keys for users, making it more accessible and secure for them to engage with decentralized applications.

Magic on the other hand has more of a hybrid approach, still using the central database to store user identities, and relies on blockchain concepts to ensure security. In summary, Magic's approach to key management relies on AWS HSM and a multi-region MySQL database to provide fast and secure access to users' private keys. However, using a semi-custodial system introduces the risk of a single point of failure, which may compromise the security of users' private keys.

  1. The Arcana Wallet

Unlike Magic, Arcana Wallet is not an add-on service. It is a utility accompanying the integration of Arcana Authentication which opens the doors for many other features. 

Arcana Wallet ensures Crypto purchases on and off ramps, so your users can simply buy crypto using credit cards and bank accounts within their In-App Wallets without needing another account on a crypto-fiat exchange.

Additionally, Arcana Wallet supports Gassless Transactions so you can provide your users with gasless transactions so that they don't have to think twice about transaction fees and can simply purchase something on your dApp without friction.

  1. Interactivity and Authentication

Arcana is accompanied by the feature of Multi-factor authentication that you can turn on if your product or service deals with sensitive information.

Arcana is very fluid with it comes to its intractability with other Web3 Products, Differing from Magic for the better, Arcana Auth is designed to interact with other Web3 products and services, which means that the user’s Arcana identity can be utilized across different blockchain networks and dApps.The Auth Service is combined with the Arcana Wallet hence making the product and pricing comfortable.

Not only that, but Using Arcana users can seamlessly sign up for your dApp using their pre-existing accounts on popular platforms such as Google, Twitter, Twitch, Discord, and others. Our platform handles the key creation and wallet setup process in a secure and non-custodial manner, ensuring the privacy and security of user data.

  1. Ease of Implementation

Integrating with Arcana is a very straightforward process as Arcana SDK has a very easy-to-implement plug-and-play functionality, The integration process consists of basic steps, which are well-documented with clear examples to guide developers through the process of building their own customized solutions. With this approach, a basic integration can be completed in around 10 minutes, requiring no additional customization for production readiness.

In addition to its numerous features, Arcana Auth provides a high degree of flexibility regarding user interface (UI) customization. Instead of being limited to a default design, users can implement their own customizable UI that aligns with their brand and dApp interface. This functionality is available in our base plan and allows for all interfaces to be tailored to meet the specific needs of users. 

Whether users opt to customize the included interfaces or leverage the 'No UI SDK' to build bespoke interfaces, Arcana Auth allows for complete control over the UX. This feature ensures that the user experience is optimized for the specific needs of each individual application, without any unnecessary constraints.

Whereas Magic, Also accompanied by strong documentation and example implementation has some additional steps of implementation and lower flexibility in terms of customization.

  1. Pricing

When it comes to pricing, Arcana Auth stands out from the competition, including Magic. Magic offers a free plan that allows for up to 1000 Monthly Active Users, after which they charge $0.05 per user. Additionally, users must pay extra for add-ons such as the Magic Wallet.

In contrast, Arcana Auth offers a free plan that supports up to 2000 Monthly Active Users and includes features such as customizable UI and wallet integration. Furthermore, even when it comes to paid plans, Arcana Auth offers a 50% lower charge of just $0.025 per Monthly Active User.

This pricing structure allows Arcana Auth to provide a cost-effective solution that meets the needs of developers and businesses of all sizes. By offering a generous free plan and affordable paid plans, Arcana Auth ensures that its platform is accessible to all, regardless of their budget or project size.

Key Features and Benefits of Arcana Authentication

Arcana Authentication is a robust security solution that provides multi-factor authentication (MFA) for businesses. Some of the key features and benefits of Arcana Authentication include:

  • Two-Factor Authentication: Arcana Authentication uses a two-factor authentication method to verify user identities, adding an extra layer of security to the authentication process. This helps to reduce the risk of unauthorized access to sensitive data.

  • Biometric Authentication: Arcana Authentication also includes biometric authentication, such as fingerprint or facial recognition, which adds an additional layer of security and ensures that only authorized users can access sensitive data.

  • Customizable Security Policies: Arcana Authentication allows businesses to set customizable security policies, which helps to ensure that users are accessing sensitive data in a secure manner. For instance, businesses can require users to change their passwords frequently or enforce strong password policies.

  • Cloud-Based Solution: Arcana Authentication is a cloud-based solution, which means that it can be easily integrated into existing IT infrastructures. This makes it a cost-effective and scalable option for businesses of all sizes.

  • Easy to Use: Arcana Authentication is user-friendly and easy to use, which means that users do not need to be IT experts to use the solution. This makes it an ideal option for businesses that want to improve their security posture without requiring extensive training for their employees.

Key Features and Benefits of Magic Authentication

Magic Authentication is another authentication solution that provides businesses with a robust security solution. Some of the key features and benefits of Magic Authentication include:

  • Multi-Factor Authentication: Magic Authentication provides multi-factor authentication (MFA), which helps to ensure that only authorized users can access sensitive data. This reduces the risk of data breaches and other security incidents.

  • Passwordless Authentication: Magic Authentication also includes passwordless authentication, which eliminates the need for users to remember complex passwords. Instead, users can use biometric authentication or other forms of authentication to access sensitive data.

  • Customizable Security Policies: Magic Authentication allows businesses to set customizable security policies, which helps to ensure that users are accessing sensitive data in a secure manner. For instance, businesses can require users to change their passwords frequently or enforce strong password policies.

  • Cloud-Based Solution: Magic Authentication is a cloud-based solution, which means that it can be easily integrated into existing IT infrastructures. This makes it a cost-effective and scalable option for businesses of all sizes.

  • Easy to Use: Magic Authentication is user-friendly and easy to use, which means that users do not need to be IT experts to use the solution. This makes it an ideal option for businesses that want to improve their security posture without requiring extensive training for their employees.

Both Arcana and Magic Authentication solutions have their unique features and benefits, and the choice of which one to use will depend on the specific needs and requirements of each business.

Arcana vs Magic: Which is the Better Authentication Solution?

When it comes to choosing an authentication solution for your business, you may be wondering which one is better: Arcana or Magic Authentication. While both solutions have their own set of unique features and benefits, there are some key differences between the two that may influence your decision.

One of the main differences between Arcana and Magic Authentication is the authentication methods they use. Arcana Authentication uses a two-factor authentication method, while Magic Authentication uses passwordless authentication. Both methods have their own advantages and disadvantages, and the one that is better for your business will depend on your specific needs and requirements.

Another key difference between the two solutions is the level of customization they offer. Both solutions allow businesses to set customizable security policies, but Arcana Authentication has a slightly more extensive set of policy options. If your business requires highly customizable security policies, Arcana may be the better option.

Additionally, Arcana Authentication has a slightly wider range of authentication methods, including biometric authentication, SMS-based authentication, and more. Magic Authentication, on the other hand, is focused on passwordless authentication and does not offer as many authentication methods.

In terms of ease of use, both solutions are user-friendly and easy to use. However, if your business has a large number of employees who may require extensive training to use a new authentication solution, Magic Authentication may be the better option due to its focus on passwordless authentication.

Overall, both Arcana and Magic Authentication are strong authentication solutions that provide businesses with robust security features. The choice of which one to use will depend on your specific needs and requirements, as well as your budget and other factors. Before making a decision, it's important to carefully evaluate the features and benefits of each solution and determine which one is the best fit for your business.

Implementing Arcana or Magic Authentication: What You Need to Know

Implementing an authentication solution like Arcana or Magic Authentication can be a complex process, but both solutions offer a range of features and benefits that make it worth the effort. Here are some key things to keep in mind when implementing these solutions:

  • Plan for Integration: Both Arcana and Magic Authentication are cloud-based solutions, which means that they can be easily integrated into your existing IT infrastructure. However, it's important to plan for integration ahead of time to ensure that the implementation process goes smoothly. This may involve working with an IT professional or a third-party provider to ensure that the solution is set up correctly.

  • Consider User Training: While both Arcana and Magic Authentication are user-friendly and easy to use, it's still important to provide your employees with adequate training on how to use the solution. This can help to minimize the risk of user errors or other issues that could compromise your organization's security.

  • Evaluate Policy Customization Options: As mentioned earlier, both Arcana and Magic Authentication offer customizable security policies. When implementing the solution, it's important to carefully evaluate these policy customization options and determine which policies are most important for your business. This may involve consulting with an IT professional or other security expert to ensure that your policies are effective.

  • Set Up Multi-Factor Authentication: One of the key features of both Arcana and Magic Authentication is multi-factor authentication (MFA). When implementing the solution, it's important to set up MFA to ensure that your organization's sensitive data is protected against unauthorized access.

  • Monitor and Update Regularly: Finally, it's important to monitor your authentication solution regularly and update it as needed. This may involve running regular security scans or working with an IT professional to ensure that the solution is up to date with the latest security patches and updates.

By keeping these key points in mind, you can successfully implement an authentication solution like Arcana or Magic Authentication and improve your organization's overall security posture.

The Takeaways

While Magic is a solid product for onboarding users into the Web3 world, it's clear that Arcana Auth has a significant advantage over them regarding core infrastructure. As a more advanced product with a stronger focus on security, non-custodial solutions, and customization options, Arcana Auth is the clear choice in almost every situation where user wallet management and recoverability are crucial factors. 

In comparison to Magic, Arcana Auth offers a more comprehensive suite of features and tools, enabling developers to build highly secure and customizable Web3 applications. By emphasizing non-custodial solutions, Arcana Auth provides a higher level of security for users, ensuring that their digital assets are always safe and secure. 

Additionally, Arcana Auth's tightly drafted documentation and quick integration support accompanied by robust customization options give developers the flexibility to create bespoke user experiences that align with their brand and design requirements. 

Overall, while Magic is a solid product for basic Web3 onboarding, Arcana Auth is the superior choice for more complex and advanced Web3 projects that require a higher level of security and customization.

Schedule a Demo

The call is completely free and no commitment is required.

Copyright © Arcana Technologies Ltd. All rights reserved.

Schedule a Demo

The call is completely free and no commitment is required.

Copyright © Arcana Technologies Ltd. All rights reserved.

Schedule a Demo

The call is completely free and no commitment is required.

Schedule a Demo

The call is completely free and no commitment is required.

Schedule a Demo

The call is completely free and no commitment is required.